American Pie Pizzeria

Note: The owner or a representative of this business has not yet completed the verification process

See more Terms of Service

4.5

( 16 reviews )

Salad, Bar & Grill

Closed 11:00 AM - 09:00 PM See Hours

927 Maple St, Carrollton, GA 30117, United States

+1 7708-323-000

American Pie Pizzeria is a beloved family-owned pizza joint located in Carrollton, GA. Known for their delicious pizzas, hot subs, salads, wings, and sizable calzones, this restaurant is a go-to destination for locals and tourists alike. Whether you're dining in, taking out, or having it delivered straight to your doorstep, American Pie Pizzeria is committed to providing their customers with the best service possible. The menu is varied and offers something for every preference. The ambiance of the restaurant is friendly and inviting, with an outstanding team of staff who are always ready to accommodate your needs. If you're in the area and looking for a fantastic pizza experience, American Pie Pizzeria is the place to be!

Reviews

4.5/5

16 reviews

5 stars

4 stars

3 stars

2 stars

1 stars

Lauren degrazia

March 22, 2024

We had a good 1st visit. We will be back. The sauce is a canned sauce. However, it is one of the better ones we have had. Once they get the first customer in for the buffet at opening, they keep the pizzas coming. Their birthday cake dessert pizza is amazing!!! The restaurant was very clean. Bathrooms were both very clean.

Gina baurile

March 22, 2024

Pizza is pretty good, not amazing, a nice change from standard big chain taste. The texture and "feel" is much more like a local hand-made pizza place instead of the factory style of chains. The "breadsticks" are just a pizza crust with garlic butter topping, but not drenched in buttery sauce like I expected based on the description, so it's mostly just a powerful hit of garlic. The butter balls are actually what I expect when I ask for breadsticks (just balls instead of sticks) but there are no pictures to show what you'd be getting. Price is moderately high; similar to "menu price" at other chains but there aren't discount codes and coupons to use like national places so it's always full-price. I'd go here occasionally just to get something different but not often due to the price.

Luke 1997

March 22, 2024

First visit here, for conveyor belt pizza it was good and fresh. Butter and Buffalo balls were enjoyable. Sauce was fairly bland but not too bad. Slices are really narrow so I felt like I ate a lot based on numbers. No salad bar with buffet but worth a try. Birthday cake pizza was surprisingly good too.

Yoman man

March 22, 2024

Good pizza for a buffet. Buffalo butter balls is where it's at!! Those were amazing! Birthday cake dessert pizza was great! We will return.

Brittany b

March 22, 2024

The food was absolutely amazing. We got a large BBQ Chicken pizza, and it was enough to feed 3 adults. My only complaint: It’s very kid-friendly, with an arcade-like feel to it. It can get pretty rowdy in there when there is a party of some sort happening. There is a seating outdoors, which I thought was nice. The dining room is also really open and features large windows for a good view. It is easily accessible to shopping and other activities, and only about 2 miles from anywhere worth visiting in Carrollton. We loved the food. We eventually got annoyed by the screaming children everywhere.

Tian yi chang

March 22, 2024

Atmosphere is rather large, open, very chill. They have long tables to accommodate larger parties. Food was enjoyable, better than the standard fast food. Staff is very friendly!

Tricia tilley

March 22, 2024

Service were all really great and friendly, they have a little lunch buffet which is what everyone I know who goes, gets. It's decent pizza for a $10 lunch buffet

Elvir henry

March 22, 2024

Ok, it's a bar first off, but a cool one. The pizza was outstanding! The beer is cold. The service was very good. There are 2 sides, one for pizza dining the other a bar. But pizza is served on both sides. We look forward to returning!